The 20 Best IBM Alternatives 2023

IBM

IBM has been a leader in the technology industry for many years, providing innovative solutions to businesses around the world. However, as the market continues to evolve, many companies are looking for alternatives to IBM that better meet their specific needs. In this article, we will explore the top 20 IBM alternatives for 2023.

The alternatives to IBM vary widely in terms of their offerings, pricing, and target markets. Some of the alternatives are established players in the industry, while others are up-and-coming startups. However, all of these alternatives have one thing in common: they offer unique solutions that can help businesses achieve their goals more effectively and efficiently.

Whether you are looking for a business process management platform, an access management solution, a data integration tool, or an integration platform as a service, there are many alternatives to IBM that can meet your needs. By exploring the top 20 IBM alternatives for 2023, you can gain a better understanding of the options available and make an informed decision about which solution is best for your business. Read More: The 10 Best Square Competitors 2023 A Complete List

Understanding IBM

IBM, or International Business Machines Corporation, is a multinational technology company that provides hardware, software, and services to clients worldwide. IBM has a long history of innovation and has been a leader in the technology industry for over a century.

IBM’s offerings include servers, storage systems, cloud computing services, artificial intelligence, blockchain, and more. The company is also known for its enterprise software solutions, including business process management, access management, and master data management.

IBM has a large and diverse customer base, including businesses of all sizes, government agencies, and educational institutions. The company has a reputation for quality and reliability, and its products and services are widely used in industries such as finance, healthcare, and manufacturing.

Despite its strengths, IBM faces stiff competition from other technology companies. Businesses looking for alternatives to IBM may consider a variety of factors, such as cost, features, and support.

In the next section, we will explore the top 20 IBM alternatives for 2023, taking into account factors such as market share, user ratings, and product offerings.

The Need for IBM Alternatives

As technology continues to evolve, businesses are constantly looking for ways to stay competitive and efficient. IBM has been a leader in the technology industry for decades, providing a wide range of products and services to businesses of all sizes. However, as with any company, IBM may not be the best fit for every business.

There are several reasons why a business may need to consider alternatives to IBM. One of the most common reasons is cost. IBM products and services can be expensive, and some businesses may not have the budget to justify the expense. In addition, some businesses may find that they are not utilizing all of the features and capabilities of IBM products, making the investment less cost-effective.

Another reason why a business may need to consider alternatives to IBM is functionality. While IBM offers a wide range of products and services, they may not always be the best fit for a business’s specific needs. For example, a business may require more specialized software or hardware that IBM does not offer, or they may need a product that is more user-friendly or easier to integrate with their existing systems.

Finally, some businesses may need to consider alternatives to IBM due to issues with customer support or service. While IBM has a reputation for providing excellent customer service and support, some businesses may have had negative experiences or may not feel that their needs are being adequately addressed.

Overall, while IBM is a respected and well-established company, there are many reasons why a business may need to consider alternatives. By carefully evaluating their needs and considering the available options, businesses can find the best fit for their specific requirements and budget.

Microsoft Azure

Microsoft Azure is a cloud computing platform and service offered by Microsoft. It provides a wide range of services, including virtual machines, web applications, and data storage, among others. Azure is a popular alternative to IBM’s cloud services, offering a robust and scalable platform for businesses of all sizes.

One of the key advantages of Microsoft Azure is its flexibility. Azure offers a wide range of services that can be customized to meet the specific needs of each business. This flexibility allows businesses to choose the services that are most relevant to their needs, without having to pay for unnecessary features.

Another advantage of Azure is its integration with other Microsoft products. Many businesses already use Microsoft products such as Office 365, and Azure can be seamlessly integrated with these products. This integration allows businesses to easily manage their cloud services and data from a single platform.

Azure also offers a range of security features to protect businesses’ data. These features include encryption, identity and access management, and threat detection. These security features help to ensure that businesses’ data is kept safe and secure.

Overall, Microsoft Azure is a robust and flexible cloud computing platform that offers a range of services to businesses of all sizes. Its integration with other Microsoft products, along with its security features and flexibility, make it a popular alternative to IBM’s cloud services.

Google Cloud Platform

Google Cloud Platform (GCP) is one of the leading cloud providers that offers a wide range of services to its customers. It is a highly scalable and reliable platform that provides cloud storage, computing, and database services. GCP is known for its advanced machine learning capabilities, which make it an ideal choice for businesses that require high-performance computing.

Key Features

GCP provides a range of features that make it a strong contender in the cloud computing market. Some of its key features include:

  • Machine Learning Capabilities: GCP offers advanced machine learning capabilities that allow businesses to build and train their own machine learning models. This feature is particularly useful for businesses that require high-performance computing.
  • Scalability: GCP is highly scalable, which means that businesses can easily scale their resources up or down depending on their needs. This feature is particularly useful for businesses that experience fluctuations in demand.
  • Reliability: GCP is a highly reliable platform that provides businesses with a 99.95% uptime guarantee. This means that businesses can rely on GCP to keep their applications running smoothly.
  • Security: GCP provides businesses with a range of security features, including data encryption, identity and access management, and network security. This makes it an ideal choice for businesses that require high levels of security.

Pricing

GCP offers a range of pricing plans that are designed to meet the needs of businesses of all sizes. Its pricing is based on a pay-as-you-go model, which means that businesses only pay for the resources they use. GCP also offers a range of discounts for long-term commitments and sustained usage.

Customer Support

GCP provides businesses with a range of customer support options, including phone and email support, as well as a knowledge base and community forum. GCP also offers a range of training and certification programs for businesses that want to improve their skills and knowledge of the platform.

Overall, GCP is a highly scalable and reliable platform that provides businesses with a range of advanced features. Its machine learning capabilities make it an ideal choice for businesses that require high-performance computing, while its security features make it a strong contender for businesses that require high levels of security.

Amazon Web Services

Amazon Web Services (AWS) is one of the most popular cloud computing platforms, offering a wide range of services that cater to various business needs. It is known for its scalability, reliability, and cost-effectiveness. AWS has a rating of 4.5 stars with 3554 reviews on Gartner Peer Insights, making it a top-rated cloud infrastructure and platform service provider.

AWS offers a wide range of services, including compute, storage, databases, analytics, machine learning, and more. Some of the popular services offered by AWS include Amazon Elastic Compute Cloud (EC2), Amazon Simple Storage Service (S3), Amazon Relational Database Service (RDS), and Amazon DynamoDB.

One of the key benefits of AWS is its scalability. AWS allows businesses to scale up or down their computing resources based on their needs, helping them save costs and avoid overprovisioning. AWS also offers flexible pricing models, including pay-as-you-go, reserved instances, and spot instances, allowing businesses to choose the most cost-effective option based on their usage patterns.

AWS also offers a range of security and compliance features, including encryption, identity and access management, and compliance certifications, making it a reliable and secure option for businesses of all sizes.

Overall, AWS is a reliable and cost-effective cloud infrastructure and platform service provider that offers a wide range of services to cater to various business needs.

Oracle Cloud

Oracle Cloud is a cloud computing platform that offers a wide range of services, including Infrastructure as a Service (IaaS), Platform as a Service (PaaS), and Software as a Service (SaaS). Oracle Cloud is a direct competitor of IBM Cloud, and it has a similar set of features and capabilities.

One of the key strengths of Oracle Cloud is its flexibility. It offers a wide range of services that can be customized to meet the specific needs of businesses. For example, businesses can choose from a range of compute, storage, and networking options to create a customized infrastructure that meets their specific needs.

Another strength of Oracle Cloud is its security. The platform provides a range of security features, including network security, data encryption, and identity and access management. These features help to protect businesses from cyber threats and ensure that their data is secure.

Oracle Cloud also offers a range of tools and services that can help businesses to manage their IT operations more efficiently. For example, the platform includes a range of management and monitoring tools that can help businesses to monitor their infrastructure, identify issues, and resolve them quickly.

Overall, Oracle Cloud is a strong alternative to IBM Cloud, particularly for businesses that are looking for a flexible and secure cloud computing platform. With its range of services and tools, Oracle Cloud can help businesses to improve their IT operations and achieve their goals more efficiently.

Alibaba Cloud

Alibaba Cloud is a cloud computing platform that offers a wide range of cloud-based services, including data storage, analytics, security, and more. It is one of the top competitors of IBM Cloud, with a rating of 4.3 stars out of 5 based on 27 reviews on Gartner Peer Insights.

Alibaba Cloud provides a range of products and services that cater to the needs of businesses of all sizes. Some of the key features of Alibaba Cloud include:

  • Elastic Computing: Alibaba Cloud offers a range of elastic computing services, including Elastic Compute Service (ECS), Elastic GPU Service (EGS), and Elastic High-Performance Computing (EHPC). These services allow businesses to scale their computing resources up or down as needed, without having to worry about hardware limitations.
  • Storage and Content Delivery: Alibaba Cloud offers a range of storage and content delivery services, including Object Storage Service (OSS), Network Attached Storage (NAS), and Content Delivery Network (CDN). These services allow businesses to store and deliver their data and content efficiently and securely.
  • Database Services: Alibaba Cloud offers a range of database services, including Relational Database Service (RDS), AnalyticDB, and Data Transmission Service (DTS). These services allow businesses to manage their databases easily and securely.
  • Security Services: Alibaba Cloud offers a range of security services, including Anti-DDoS, Web Application Firewall (WAF), and Security Center. These services help businesses protect their applications and data from cyber threats.

Alibaba Cloud is known for its competitive pricing and flexible payment options. It offers pay-as-you-go and subscription-based pricing models, as well as discounts for long-term commitments.

Overall, Alibaba Cloud is a reliable and cost-effective alternative to IBM Cloud for businesses looking for a cloud computing platform that can meet their diverse needs.

Salesforce

Salesforce is a cloud-based customer relationship management (CRM) software that provides businesses with a range of tools to manage their sales, marketing, and customer service operations. It is one of the most popular CRM software in the market and is used by businesses of all sizes.

Salesforce offers a range of features and functionalities that make it a great alternative to IBM. Some of the key features of Salesforce include:

  • Customizable dashboards: Salesforce allows businesses to create custom dashboards that provide real-time insights into their sales, marketing, and customer service operations. These dashboards can be customized to show only the metrics that matter most to the business.
  • Mobile app: Salesforce offers a mobile app that allows users to access their CRM data on the go. The app is available for both iOS and Android devices and provides users with access to all the features of the desktop version of Salesforce.
  • Collaboration tools: Salesforce offers a range of collaboration tools that make it easy for teams to work together. These tools include Chatter, which is a social network for businesses, and Salesforce Files, which is a file-sharing platform.
  • Marketing automation: Salesforce offers a range of marketing automation tools that make it easy for businesses to create and manage marketing campaigns. These tools include email marketing, social media marketing, and lead management.
  • Customer service tools: Salesforce offers a range of customer service tools that make it easy for businesses to manage their customer support operations. These tools include case management, knowledge management, and live chat.

Overall, Salesforce is a great alternative to IBM for businesses that are looking for a cloud-based CRM software with a range of features and functionalities. It is easy to use, customizable, and offers great customer support.

SAP

SAP is a leading provider of enterprise software solutions that help businesses manage their operations and processes. It offers a wide range of products and services, including enterprise resource planning (ERP), customer relationship management (CRM), supply chain management (SCM), and more. SAP is a popular alternative to IBM for businesses looking for a comprehensive software suite that can help them streamline their operations and improve their bottom line.

One of the key benefits of SAP is its ability to integrate with other software solutions and platforms. This means that businesses can use SAP alongside other tools and systems to create a more cohesive and efficient workflow. SAP also offers a wide range of customization options, allowing businesses to tailor the software to their specific needs and requirements.

Another advantage of SAP is its focus on data analytics and business intelligence. The software includes powerful analytics tools that can help businesses gain insights into their operations, identify trends, and make data-driven decisions. This can be especially useful for businesses that operate in complex or highly regulated industries.

SAP also offers a range of industry-specific solutions, such as SAP for Retail, SAP for Banking, and SAP for Utilities. These solutions are designed to meet the unique needs and challenges of specific industries, and can help businesses in those industries achieve greater efficiency and profitability.

Overall, SAP is a strong alternative to IBM for businesses looking for a comprehensive software solution that can help them manage their operations and processes. Its focus on data analytics, customization, and industry-specific solutions make it a popular choice for businesses of all sizes and industries.

Red Hat

Red Hat is a well-known open-source software company that provides various solutions for enterprise-level applications. It offers a wide range of products and services for application development, integration, and management, including Red Hat Enterprise Linux, Red Hat OpenShift, and JBoss Enterprise Application Platform.

Red Hat’s products are known for their reliability, scalability, and security, making them a popular choice for businesses looking for enterprise-level solutions. Red Hat’s open-source approach also allows for greater flexibility and customization, making it a popular choice for developers.

Some of the key features of Red Hat’s products include:

  • Scalability: Red Hat’s products are designed to scale with the needs of the business, allowing for greater flexibility and growth.
  • Security: Red Hat’s products are known for their robust security features, including built-in security protocols and regular updates.
  • Integration: Red Hat’s products are designed to integrate seamlessly with other systems and applications, making it easier to manage complex enterprise-level environments.
  • Customization: Red Hat’s open-source approach allows for greater customization and flexibility, making it easier to tailor solutions to the specific needs of the business.

Red Hat is a popular alternative to IBM for businesses looking for enterprise-level solutions. Its open-source approach, reliability, and security features make it a popular choice for developers and businesses alike.

VMware

VMware is a popular virtualization software that allows users to run multiple operating systems on a single computer. It is widely used in enterprise environments and has been a dominant player in the virtualization market for many years. However, there are several alternatives to VMware that offer similar or even better features.

One of the main competitors of VMware is Microsoft’s Hyper-V. Hyper-V is a built-in feature of Windows Server and offers many of the same features as VMware, such as virtual machine management, virtual networking, and virtual storage. Hyper-V is also more affordable than VMware, as it is included in the cost of Windows Server.

Another alternative to VMware is Citrix Hypervisor. Citrix Hypervisor is a powerful virtualization platform that offers high performance, scalability, and security. It is also more affordable than VMware and offers a wide range of features, including support for multiple operating systems, virtual networking, and virtual storage.

Nutanix is another popular virtualization platform that is often compared to VMware. Nutanix offers a hyperconverged infrastructure that combines compute, storage, and networking into a single platform. This makes it easier to manage and scale virtual environments, as everything is integrated into a single system. Nutanix also offers a wide range of features, including support for multiple hypervisors, virtual networking, and virtual storage.

Other alternatives to VMware include Red Hat Virtualization, Oracle VM VirtualBox, and Parallels Desktop. Each of these platforms offers unique features and benefits, and it is important to consider the specific needs of your organization when choosing a virtualization platform.

Overall, while VMware is a popular and powerful virtualization platform, there are several alternatives that offer similar or even better features. It is important to carefully evaluate each platform and choose the one that best meets the needs of your organization.

Rackspace

Rackspace is a leading provider of cloud computing services that offers a range of alternatives to IBM’s cloud services. With a focus on managed cloud services, Rackspace provides businesses with the expertise and support they need to migrate to the cloud and optimize their cloud infrastructure.

One of the key advantages of Rackspace is its Fanatical Support®. This service provides businesses with 24x7x365 access to certified cloud engineers who can help with everything from cloud planning and design to migration and ongoing management. This level of support is particularly valuable for businesses that lack in-house cloud expertise.

Rackspace offers a range of cloud services, including public, private, and hybrid cloud solutions. Its public cloud services are built on OpenStack, an open-source cloud computing platform, and offer a range of features, including compute, storage, and networking services. Rackspace’s private cloud solutions, on the other hand, provide businesses with dedicated cloud infrastructure that is tailored to their specific needs.

In addition to its cloud services, Rackspace also offers a range of managed services, including managed security, managed databases, and managed applications. These services can help businesses to reduce their IT overheads and focus on their core business activities.

Overall, Rackspace offers a range of alternatives to IBM’s cloud services that are well-suited to businesses of all sizes. With its Fanatical Support® and range of cloud and managed services, Rackspace can help businesses to optimize their cloud infrastructure and achieve their business goals.

DigitalOcean

DigitalOcean is a cloud infrastructure provider that offers a simple and easy-to-use platform for developers to deploy and manage their applications. It is known for its fast and reliable SSD-based virtual machines, flexible pricing plans, and user-friendly interface.

DigitalOcean is a great alternative to IBM for small to medium-sized businesses and startups that need a scalable and affordable cloud infrastructure. It offers a range of features and services, including:

  • Droplets: Virtual machines that can be deployed in seconds and customized to meet specific requirements.
  • Block Storage: Highly available and scalable SSD-based storage for applications and data.
  • Spaces: Object storage for unstructured data, such as images, videos, and backups.
  • Load Balancers: A simple and cost-effective way to distribute incoming traffic across multiple Droplets.
  • Kubernetes: A managed Kubernetes service that simplifies the deployment, scaling, and management of containerized applications.

DigitalOcean is also known for its excellent customer support, which includes a comprehensive knowledge base, community forums, and 24/7 technical support. Its pricing plans are transparent and flexible, with no hidden fees or long-term commitments.

Overall, DigitalOcean is a reliable and affordable alternative to IBM for businesses that need a simple and scalable cloud infrastructure. Its user-friendly interface, fast SSD-based virtual machines, and flexible pricing plans make it a popular choice among developers and startups.

CloudSigma

CloudSigma is a cloud computing provider that offers a range of services, including Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS), Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS), and Software-as-a-Service (SaaS). The company was founded in 2009 and has headquarters in Switzerland.

CloudSigma is a strong alternative to IBM Cloud, with a focus on flexibility and customization. The company offers a pay-as-you-go pricing model, which allows users to scale their resources up or down as needed. This can be especially useful for businesses with fluctuating workloads or seasonal demand.

In terms of infrastructure, CloudSigma offers a high-performance, all-SSD storage system, which can provide fast access to data. The company also offers a range of virtualization options, including KVM, VMware, and Hyper-V.

One of the key advantages of CloudSigma is the ability to customize virtual machines (VMs) to meet specific requirements. Users can select the amount of CPU, RAM, and storage they need, as well as choose from a range of operating systems and applications.

CloudSigma also offers a range of security features, including firewalls, VPNs, and intrusion detection and prevention. The company is compliant with a range of standards, including ISO 27001, SOC 2, and HIPAA.

Overall, CloudSigma is a strong alternative to IBM Cloud, offering a flexible, customizable, and secure cloud computing platform.

Linode

Linode is a cloud hosting provider that offers Linux-based virtual private servers (VPS) with a range of features and pricing options. It has been in the market for over a decade and has gained a reputation for providing reliable and high-performance services to its users.

One of the main advantages of Linode is its pricing structure, which is straightforward and transparent. Users can choose from a variety of plans based on their needs, with prices ranging from $5 to $960 per month. The plans differ in terms of storage, RAM, CPU, and bandwidth, among other factors. Linode also offers hourly billing, which can be useful for users who need to scale their resources up or down quickly.

Linode’s platform is designed to offer flexibility and control to its users. It provides a range of tools and features to manage VPS instances, including a web-based control panel, a command-line interface, an API, and mobile apps. Users can also choose from a variety of Linux distributions, including Ubuntu, Debian, CentOS, and Fedora.

Linode has a strong focus on security and reliability. It provides several security features, such as two-factor authentication, SSH key management, and DDoS protection. It also offers a 99.9% uptime guarantee and 24/7 support through email, phone, and chat.

Overall, Linode is a solid choice for users who need a reliable and flexible cloud hosting provider. Its pricing structure, range of features, and focus on security and reliability make it a strong competitor in the market.

Vultr

Vultr is a cloud hosting provider that offers scalable and flexible hosting solutions for businesses of all sizes. It was founded in 2014 and has since become a popular alternative to IBM for those looking for affordable and reliable cloud hosting.

Features

Vultr provides a number of features that make it a great option for businesses. Some of its key features include:

  • High-performance SSD storage
  • Custom ISOs and snapshots
  • 100% Intel CPUs
  • Multiple server locations around the world
  • Hourly billing with no long-term contracts
  • Easy-to-use control panel

Pricing

Vultr offers a variety of pricing plans to meet the needs of different businesses. Its plans range from $2.50 per month to $640 per month, depending on the amount of resources required. All plans come with a 100% SLA and a 30-day money-back guarantee.

Alternatives

While Vultr is a great option for many businesses, it may not be the best fit for everyone. Some of the top alternatives to Vultr include:

  • Kamatera
  • Scaleway
  • DigitalOcean
  • Linode
  • AWS

Each of these providers offers its own unique set of features and pricing plans, so it’s important to do your research and choose the one that best fits your business needs.

IBM Alternatives for Small Businesses

IBM is a leading technology company that offers a wide range of products and services to businesses of all sizes. However, small businesses may find IBM solutions to be too complex or expensive for their needs. Fortunately, there are several IBM alternatives that are specifically designed for small businesses. Here are some of the best options:

1. Microsoft

Microsoft is a well-known technology company that offers a variety of products and services for small businesses. Its Office 365 suite includes popular productivity tools like Word, Excel, and PowerPoint, as well as cloud storage and collaboration features. Additionally, Microsoft offers a range of other solutions, including Azure cloud services and Dynamics 365 business applications.

2. Google

Google is another popular technology company that offers a range of solutions for small businesses. Its G Suite includes productivity tools like Gmail, Google Drive, and Google Docs, as well as collaboration features and cloud storage. Additionally, Google offers a range of other solutions, including Google Cloud Platform and Google Analytics.

3. Amazon Web Services

Amazon Web Services (AWS) is a cloud computing platform that offers a range of services for small businesses. Its offerings include compute, storage, and database services, as well as analytics, machine learning, and Internet of Things (IoT) solutions. Additionally, AWS offers a range of other solutions, including Amazon WorkSpaces and Amazon Chime.

4. Oracle

Oracle is a technology company that offers a range of solutions for small businesses. Its offerings include cloud applications, database and middleware solutions, and hardware products. Additionally, Oracle offers a range of other solutions, including Oracle Cloud Infrastructure and Oracle Analytics Cloud.

5. SAP

SAP is a software company that offers a range of solutions for small businesses. Its offerings include enterprise resource planning (ERP) solutions, customer relationship management (CRM) solutions, and supply chain management (SCM) solutions. Additionally, SAP offers a range of other solutions, including SAP HANA and SAP Cloud Platform.

Overall, small businesses have several IBM alternatives to choose from. These solutions offer a range of features and benefits that can help small businesses improve their productivity, collaboration, and efficiency. By evaluating their needs and selecting the best solution for their business, small business owners can find a technology solution that meets their needs and fits within their budget.

IBM Alternatives for Enterprises

Enterprises looking for alternatives to IBM have many options to choose from. Here are some of the best IBM alternatives for enterprises:

1. Microsoft Azure

Microsoft Azure is a cloud computing platform that provides a wide range of services, including virtual machines, web applications, and storage. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a scalable and flexible cloud solution.

2. Amazon Web Services (AWS)

Amazon Web Services (AWS) is a cloud computing platform that provides a wide range of services, including storage, computing, and databases. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a reliable and scalable cloud solution.

3. Google Cloud Platform

Google Cloud Platform is a cloud computing platform that provides a wide range of services, including compute, storage, and networking. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a flexible and cost-effective cloud solution.

4. Oracle Cloud Infrastructure

Oracle Cloud Infrastructure is a cloud computing platform that provides a wide range of services, including compute, storage, and networking. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a secure and reliable cloud solution.

5. Salesforce

Salesforce is a cloud-based customer relationship management (CRM) platform that provides a wide range of services, including sales, marketing, and customer service. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a comprehensive CRM solution.

6. SAP

SAP is a software company that provides a wide range of enterprise software solutions, including ERP, CRM, and supply chain management. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a comprehensive software solution.

7. ServiceNow

ServiceNow is a cloud-based platform that provides a wide range of services, including IT service management, HR service management, and customer service management. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want an integrated service management solution.

8. Workday

Workday is a cloud-based platform that provides a wide range of services, including HR management, financial management, and analytics. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a comprehensive HR and finance solution.

9. Atlassian

Atlassian is a software company that provides a wide range of enterprise software solutions, including project management, collaboration, and development tools. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a comprehensive software solution.

10. Red Hat

Red Hat is a software company that provides a wide range of enterprise software solutions, including operating systems, middleware, and virtualization. It is a popular choice for enterprises that want a comprehensive software solution.

Enterprises looking for alternatives to IBM should consider these options based on their specific needs and requirements. Each of these alternatives offers a unique set of features and benefits, so it is important to evaluate them carefully before making a decision.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*